The Case for and Against Dark Souls 3 Getting the Demon’s Souls Remake Treatment

Posted by By our-little-miss-is-home December 1, 2024 7 Views 6 Min Read
The Case for and Against Dark Souls 3 Getting the Demon's Souls Remake Treatment



Dark Souls 3 is a highly acclaimed action role-playing title whose dark theme and gripping gameplay has captured the adoration of many. Being one of the older FromSoftware games, one wonders if it should be given the same remake treatment as one of its predecessors, Demon’s Souls. While Dark Souls 3 has the potential to benefit from the decision, there is also the argument that there is no need for it to undergo an enhancement.




On March 24, 2016, Dark Souls 3 was released to the public and was well-received by fans of the Dark Souls series. It has been over 8 years since then, and the game being remade by FromSoftware is a possibility. Among the titles in the Dark Souls series, Dark Souls 3 can be seen as the one that has aged better and more timeless than its predecessors, making it a suitable candidate for a remake. However, it is also because of those qualities that can make one say that it shouldn’t be improved upon.

10 Hardest Demon Bosses in the Dark Souls Series capra demon, demon prince, and demon firesage

Related
10 Hardest Demon Bosses in the Dark Souls Series

Across the Dark Souls games, there are plenty of horrifying demons that players must face.

The Case for Dark Souls 3 Being Remade Like Demon’s Souls


Demon’s Souls being remade meant big things for the Dark Souls series of games, as it showed the possibility of any one of them getting the same treatment at some point. FromSoftware has yet to make it happen, but that does not mean it never will. If the developer were to choose which entry in the Souls series to remake, then it’s likely to pick Dark Souls 3. Improving an already great game could revitalize its place in pop culture while also attracting new fans. There are further reasons why it deserves to be remade:

  • The limited amount of Dark Souls 3 New Game Plus content when compared to Dark Souls 2 means that a remake can add more to ensure there are even more challenges to enjoy and overcome
  • Being on the easier side when compared to its predecessors, a remake could add a new tier of difficulty with features like making dodge rolls have fewer invincibility frames or changing the damage output of certain enemies
  • The remake could add new tools and weapon types for players, bring back some from the previous games, or change the effects and stats of the current options


Why Dark Souls 3 Should Not Be Remade

While a remake of Dark Souls 3 would presumably receive the same graphical improvements that Demon’s Souls got, the visuals alone do not justify an overhaul. Even when compared to today’s standards, the world and character design of the third game in the Dark Souls series still holds up quite well. As one of the FromSoftware games with the best narrative, combat feel, boss battles, etc., it is still a game whose quality allows it to match or surpass that of modern Soulslike titles, meaning a remake could ultimately feel unnecessary. While it can be said that remaking Dark Souls 3 could make it even greater, there is the possibility that whatever changes it receives will make it worse, leaving a stain on the third game of the series that shouldn’t even be there.

The best thing about each Dark Souls game is that they all balance empowering gameplay with a proper challenge; Dark Souls 3 can be seen as one of the best examples of a title that defines tough but fair gameplay. Even after eight years, fans still hold it in high regard, which makes it a logical choice for being remade in the same way as Demon’s Souls. But whether it will or not depends entirely on FromSoftware. As the masterpiece of a game that it is, perhaps there’s no need to improve upon it.


Source link