The Until Dawn Movie Is Worse As A Straight Adaptation

The upcoming Until Dawn movie has sparked mixed reactions, with some fans disappointed that it won’t be a direct adaptation of the beloved 2015 horror game and its more recent remake. The interactive story, which allowed players to make choices that impacted the survival of the cast, became a modern cult classic in the horror gaming space. It became one of the most beloved games of this genre precisely because it offered a unique story with unique actors and graphics that were quite impressive, especially given when the title released. Given its cinematic presentation and slasher-movie influences, many assumed that a film adaptation would simply bring the game’s story to the big screen. However, when the Until Dawn movie was announced, the filmmakers made it clear early that it would not be a direct adaptation.

Instead, the film is taking a more creative approach by using a key mechanic from the Until Dawn game—choices and branching paths—to craft an entirely new horror experience. And the filmmakers took that mechanic and made it theirs. They also did it pretty much the only way someone could put that mechanic into a movie that isn’t interactive. This opens the door to fresh storytelling, ensuring that the adaptation isn’t just a rehash of the game. More intriguingly, the film’s structure may allow characters to shift through different horror genres, keeping the narrative engaging and unpredictable.

Related

What Even Is The Point Of Until Dawn’s Movie Adaptation?

Sony’s upcoming adaptation of Until Dawn feels pointless. Apart from having the same title and the same general premise, it’s basically a completely different IP. Based on the trailer, it does look like a decent mystery/slasher flick, but with the whole time rewind thing going on, perhaps they might as well have ditched the whole adaptation thing altogether and named it something else.

A More Creative Approach Makes for a More Exciting Film

At first glance, Until Dawn seems like a game perfectly suited for a straight movie adaptation. The game already feels like a cinematic experience, borrowing heavily from classic horror tropes, especially the teen slasher subgenre. It features a group of young adults stranded in a remote cabin, stalked by an unseen threat, and makes use of cinematic framing, recognizable actors, and suspenseful set pieces. However, what made Until Dawn truly engaging was not just its story but its interactive nature.

The core appeal of Until Dawn was the ability to influence events through player choices. Every decision had consequences, shaping the fates of the characters and leading to multiple endings. A linear film adaptation would strip away this interactive component, leaving a story that, while enjoyable, wouldn’t be particularly unique among the countless slasher films already available. By focusing on a fresh take rather than a direct adaptation, the film has a chance to be more than just another horror movie.

Rather than retreading the same narrative beats, the Until Dawn movie is taking a more inventive approach, reportedly using a key game mechanic as the foundation for its storytelling. This mechanic in the movie will show that people need to survive until dawn in order to get out of the house they find themselves in during the trailers. And if they fail and die, the genre of the horror the characters are going through.

This concept not only preserves what made the game special but also makes the film unique in its own right. If the movie manages to integrate the feeling of player choice into its storytelling—whether through unreliable narrators, shifting timelines, or supernatural elements—it could deliver an experience that pays homage to the game while standing on its own as a compelling horror film.

Exploring Multiple Horror Genres Adds to the Fun

One of the most exciting possibilities for the Until Dawn movie is that suggestion that characters may find themselves shifting through different horror genres. The original game was heavily inspired by slashers, but it also incorporated elements of psychological horror, creature horror, and supernatural terror. Expanding on this idea in the film could make for a truly dynamic horror experience.

Imagine a movie where the characters unknowingly step from one horror trope to another—one moment trapped in a Friday the 13th-style slasher scenario, the next lost in a Lovecraftian nightmare or caught in a found-footage-style supernatural encounter. This would not only make the film unpredictable but also serve as a meta-commentary on horror itself, similar to what Cabin in the Woods accomplished. Rather than being confined to a single, expected narrative, this approach allows Until Dawn to remain surprising even for those who have played the game.

A Better Way to Bring Until Dawn to the Big Screen

The decision to move away from a straight adaptation of Until Dawn might initially disappoint some fans, but it’s ultimately the right call. The game thrived on its interactive nature, and simply copying its plot into a film would have made for a less compelling experience. By embracing the game’s unique mechanics and playing with different horror genres, the movie has the potential to be something far more creative and engaging.

Rather than just recreating the past, the Until Dawn movie is taking the spirit of the game and using it as a foundation for something new. If done right, it could be one of the most innovative horror adaptations to date—one that captures the essence of what made the game special while standing as a thrilling experience in its own right.

Until Dawn

Release Date

April 23, 2025

Director

David F. Sandberg

Writers

Gary Dauberman, Blair Butler

Producers

Carter Swan, Roy Lee, Gary Dauberman, Charles Miller, Lotta Losten, Asad Qizilbash

• 

  Peter Stormare

  Dr. Alan J. Hill

• 
• 
• 

More

This Movie Proves Until Dawn Can Succeed Even Straying From Its Source Material

Can the Until Dawn movie succeed by veering from its source material? Here’s why a fresh approach might echo the success of a similar project.