Key Takeaways
- Blackbeard and Luffy share similar goals but differ in methods in One Piece.
- Blackbeard’s ruthless cunning sets him apart from Luffy’s free-spirited journey.
- The dynamic between Luffy and Blackbeard showcases an ideological clash awaiting in the series.
While One Piece has a wide assortment of amazing heroes, many times throughout the series, the villains are actually the franchise’s most beloved and well-developed characters. Often featuring interesting motivations, sleek designs, and charismatic personalities, these bad guys steal every scene they are in. From Crocodile to Doffy, it’s hard to think of a major villain in One Piece that has failed to live up to expectations, besides Hody Jones.
However, no other villain in One Piece seems to match the same level of story-significance and cruel charisma of the Emperor of the Seas, and the most underhanded pirate, Blackbeard. Blackbeard throughout the story has always been an amazing addition, providing an evil parallel to the franchise’s hero, Monkey D. Luffy. This amazing dynamic shows that Luffy and Blackbeard are more similar than some fans would expect, functioning as opposite sides of the same coin.
Related
One Piece: Carrot Deserves Better
Despite doing so much for the Straw Hat Crew, Carrot has a disappointing send-off in One Piece.
Blackbeard and Luffy: Two Different Sides of the Same Coin
An Interesting Dynamic
Blackbeard was first introduced to the world of One Piece in the Jaya Arc, a smaller arc that takes place before Skypiea. In this arc, the audience is introduced to most of Blackbeard’s original crew members, as well as the captain himself, Marshall D. Teach. When Luffy meets the ruthless pirate, the duo argue over the quality of cherry pie, in a fairly goofy, but enjoyable scene.
The era where pirates have dreams will be over, they say? Huh? People’s dreams have no end! Isn’t that right? – Blackbeard to Luffy
After, One Piece’s Blackbeard and Luffy have a peculiar discussion about dreams and the existence of a Sky Island, where it turns out that Blackbeard is the only individual in Jaya who believes these things exist. Here, we also learn of Blackbeard’s passion for finding the One Piece and his goal of becoming the King of the Pirates, just like Luffy. However, besides most of their interactions being cordial, Luffy senses something off from the jolly pirate.
Blackbeard and Luffy Have Parallel Story Arcs in One Piece
Similar Goals, Similar Drive
From here, the duo of Luffy and Blackbeard progress through a parallel story arc in One Piece, with both causing massive waves in the world and quickly finding their way as Emperors of the Sea. With both characters having a similar crew, similar motivations, similar happy-go-lucky attitudes, and similar dreams, Luffy and Blackbeard almost feel like a mirror of one another. However, between the two characters, there is one major difference; the means of achieving their goals.
As many already know, to achieve his goals, the Straw Hat Captain will do whatever he wants, with little thinking or planning going into it. For Luffy, this is the ultimate freedom, sailing the open seas, doing whatever comes to mind, and eventually reaching the end goal of becoming the Pirate King. While he does have many crew members to help reel him in when he strays a bit too far from the beaten path, since the beginning of their adventures, the Straw Hats have often traveled to wherever the wind takes them.
Related
One Piece: Did Time Skip Ruin Franky’s Character?
Time skip changed a lot for the Straw Hat crew in One Piece, but did it also ruin Franky’s character.
As for Blackbeard, one of One Piece’s most important villains, his journey to the top, rather than focusing on exploring to his heart’s content, focuses purely on a plan for success. In his plan, Blackbeard has amassed a deadly crew from Impel Down, captured some of the most powerful Devil Fruits in the series, and made his way to the role of Emperor. While Luffy would often help others on a whim, Blackbeard only helps others when they have something to offer him, oppressing them into his overall strategy with ruthless cunning.
Blackbeard’s Ruthless Cunning Sets Him Apart From Luffy
Luffy’s True Antithesis
In a way, while both Blackbeard and Luffy have the same motivation in One Piece, the difference in their strategies for success highlights the beautiful aspects of their dynamic. One Piece is a story about freedom and adventure on the open seas, and while at first the One Piece villain, Blackbeard, seems like he shares this dream with Luffy, in reality, he doesn’t. Luffy will always take into account the freedom of others when it comes to his journey to become the Pirate King. However, Blackbeard will capture and kill anyone in his path, the antithesis of the freedom Luffy strives for.
Fate Has Chosen Me To Conquer This World! – Blackbeard
So far, Blackbeard and Luffy have been two of the best-developed characters in all of One Piece, and it will be interesting to see where they go. Hopefully, by the end of One Piece’s Final Saga, the two will clash, both physically and ideologically. Maybe then fans will finally see whose strategy to become the Pirate King is better.
