Travis Bruno of Capsule Computers writes:
“When it comes to myths, legends, and different types of magic players are likely familiar with many of the common tropes and those that come from ancient European culture, but they are likely quite unfamiliar with those from America, especially from the American Deep South. Sure, there are occasionally tales of voodoo and whispers of dark magics in the bayou, but these are barely explored in most media, let alone in video games. That is something that makes South of Midnight so special. Compulsion Games has crafted something of a love letter to this untapped lore by providing an emotionally impactful narrative presented with a unique visual style and a glorious soundtrack even if it does have some issues along the way.”