If Persona 4 Gets a Remake, One Feature From Persona 3 Reload is a Shoo-In

The Persona series is no stranger to evolving its core systems with each new iteration. From the introduction of Social Links in Persona 3 to the mix of turn-based and real-time elements in Metaphor: ReFantazio, Atlus continuously refines its gameplay. One of the clearest examples of this evolution is Shift, the streamlined combat mechanic introduced in Persona 3 Reload.

Adapted from Persona 5’s Baton Pass, Shift enables more fluid and strategic gameplay by letting party members pass their turns after hitting an enemy’s weakness. This not only opens up combo possibilities but also ensures that players can maintain tempo in combat. With rumors circulating around a potential Persona 4 remake, there’s little doubt that Shift would make the jump once again.

Related

The Rumored Persona 4 Remake Would Likely Avoid One Controversy Persona 3 Reload Couldn’t

A remake of Persona 4 would be able to avoid a major controversy that faced Persona 3 Reload, the previous remake of a Persona title.

Shift Makes Persona 4 Battles More Dynamic

In Persona 3 Reload, Shift is more than a mere quality-of-life feature. It deepens turn-based encounters by rewarding player foresight and team synergy. When a character lands an attack that targets an enemy’s weakness, they can choose to “shift” their turn to another party member, who gains a buff and a fresh action. It brings momentum into battle while encouraging players to think two or three moves ahead.

Persona 4, with its randomized dungeons and traditional “One More” turn system, could benefit immensely from this added layer of control. For example, if Chie lands a knockdown with Mabufu, she could Shift to Yukiko, who uses Agilao with the benefit of a Shift Boost skill to deal extra fire damage to a grouped enemy. This creates exciting, layered encounters even in otherwise standard fights. Imagine combining Shift Amp with a character like Naoto, whose elemental coverage makes her an ideal follow-up attacker. The result? Strategic domination.

This mechanic also remedies one of Persona 4’s original frustrations: tempo loss from AI party members. While Persona 4 Golden already added manual control of teammates, incorporating Shift would emphasize player agency even further. The only drawback is that, as seen in Persona 3 Reload, AI-controlled characters currently do not utilize Shift. A Persona 4 remake would need to update that behavior or keep full control in the player’s hands to ensure consistency.

Shift Reflects Persona 4’s Core Teamwork Themes

Beyond gameplay, Shift fits tonally with Persona 4’s themes. The game centers around building trust within a small-town group of unlikely friends. Each character learns to confront their Shadow—the repressed version of themselves—and only after that confrontation are they truly able to fight together. Shift, in its very design, reinforces the idea of leaning on allies and empowering others when the time is right.

One could take Kanji in Persona 4 Golden as an example. He starts the game withdrawn, with his struggles tied to how others perceive him. In battle, however, giving him a buffed turn through Shift could reflect the group’s growing trust in his strength. Similarly, Rise, who doesn’t directly fight, could receive a visual Shift-style prompt for support skills, showcasing her behind-the-scenes contributions.

Atlus has already shown in Persona 3 Reload that it’s willing to use mechanics to reinforce themes. By letting a character “Shift” trust to another party member, it subtly mirrors how bonds are built across the story. Bringing this mechanic to a Persona 4 remake would harmonize gameplay and narrative in a way that earlier versions never fully managed.

Related

Persona 4: 7 Things The Remake Needs

If you’re wondering what could be improved in a Persona 4 remake, we’ve got some ideas.

Persona 4’s Dungeons Could Change With Shift

A potential Persona 4 remake faces another fork in the road: dungeon design. Persona 3 Reload modernized its dungeon Tartarus, moving away from endless corridors to more handcrafted, visually distinct environments. Meanwhile, Persona 5 set a high bar with palaces that visually reflected the subconscious mind of their owners. Persona 4’s dungeons already leaned in that direction—each one was themed after a character’s inner struggles, from Yukiko’s castle to Kanji’s bathhouse.

However, these spaces were still largely procedural in layout. A remake could reimagine them as fixed maps with unique puzzles and scripted enemy encounters that make the most of Shift’s tactical flexibility. For instance, inside Naoto’s Secret Laboratory dungeon, the remake could place enemies in tighter formations, daring players to use Shift to chain elemental attacks effectively. A puzzle room where defeating enemies in the correct order grants buffs would directly tie into mastering the mechanic.

Even the UI could reflect the game’s TV motif. Instead of simply saying “Shift,” the game could use TV-themed prompts like “Cut to” or “Spotlight,” in line with Persona 4’s Midnight Channel setting. Visual flourishes, like a camera transition when switching turns, could enhance both gameplay and immersion.

Bringing Shift into a Persona 4 remake isn’t just likely—it’s a natural extension of what Atlus already considers a cornerstone of modern Persona combat. From thematic reinforcement to improved strategic options and potential dungeon reworks, the groundwork is already laid. With the success of Persona 3 Reload, the message is clear: the future of Persona includes Shift, and it’s just waiting for the next cast of characters to take the stage.

Released

December 9, 2008

ESRB

M For Mature 17+ due to Alcohol Reference, Animated Blood, Language, Partial Nudity, Sexual Themes, Violence