Games With Unsatisfying Endings That Fit The Story

This list contains spoilers!

Not every story needs a happy ending. Sometimes, what lingers after the credits roll isn’t triumph or closure, but a deep, nagging ache, the kind that sticks in the ribs for days. These are the stories where the finale doesn’t tie things up with a bow but instead leaves things frayed, unresolved, or downright tragic.

Related

10 Video Games With The Most Satisfying Endings, Ranked

These video games have some of the most satisfying endings ever, even if some of them do give us all of the feels.

And yet, it’s exactly what the story needed. The kind of endings that feel wrong in all the right ways.

6

Spec Ops: The Line

War Is Hell, And So Is Realizing You’re The Villain

Released

June 26, 2012

Developer(s)

Yager Development

ESRB

M For Mature 17+ Due To Blood and Gore, Intense Violence, Strong Language

There’s no grand victory waiting at the end of Spec Ops: The Line. No medal ceremony, no righteous justification, just the slow unraveling of a soldier’s psyche in a warzone that stopped making sense long ago. What starts as a standard military shooter quickly turns into one of the most psychologically harrowing narratives in modern gaming — a deliberate descent into moral rot.

Captain Martin Walker arrives in Dubai to rescue survivors after a devastating sandstorm, but every decision made after that spirals into chaos. Players expecting a clear good-versus-evil arc get something far messier — choices that feel wrong no matter what, a body count that grows increasingly senseless, and the creeping realization that none of it was heroic.

By the time the ending hits, there’s no redemption left to salvage. Whether Walker survives or not, the weight of his actions can’t be erased. The infamous white phosphorus scene is like a mirror held up to the player, forcing them to confront what they participated in. It’s an ending that feels hollow, broken, and uncomfortable. But in a story about the horrors of war and the fragility of morality, it fits like a bullet casing hitting the floor.

5

Inside

The Final Stretch Is A Crawl, But So Was The Whole Journey

Released

June 29, 2016

Developer(s)

Playdead

ESRB

M For Mature 17+ due to Blood and Gore, Violence

Nothing about Inside tries to explain itself — not the silent boy in the red shirt, not the eerie, dystopian world he moves through, and certainly not the ending that’s been dissected more times than any puzzle in the game itself. But that’s part of the unease that makes it so haunting.

From the very start, everything feels off. People stand motionless under some unseen control, grotesque experiments twitch behind glass panels, and security drones stalk the shadows. And then there’s that ending, where the protagonist becomes a writhing mass of flesh, limbs, and screams known as the Huddle, breaking out of the research facility only to slump lifelessly in the sunlight.

It’s deliberately unsatisfying; there’s no revelation about who the boy was or what the facility was doing. No sense of victory. Just the implication that whatever was driving him, it may not have been free will at all. Some believe he was being controlled the whole time. Others think he was the controller. But the ambiguity is the point of the game. It’s the final, oppressive note in a story where control was always an illusion.

4

Telltale’s The Walking Dead Season 1

Sometimes Goodbye Is The Hardest Choice, Even When It’s The Only One

Released

April 24, 2012

ESRB

Mature 17+ // Blood and Gore, Drug Reference, Intense Violence, Sexual Themes, Strong Language

Few endings hit as hard as Lee Everett’s final moments in Telltale’s The Walking Dead: Season 1. After hours of protecting Clementine from walkers, strangers, and every form of human cruelty, Lee finds himself bitten — a slow death sentence in a world that doesn’t have time for grief.

Related

The 7 Most Satisfying Endings in Video Games, Ranked

A great video game knows how to reward fans with a proper payoff in the end. Here’s which video games absolutely nailed their endings.

The last scenes are devastating not because of gore or spectacle, but because of what’s asked of Clementine. She has to say goodbye to the only person who kept her alive and taught her how to survive, and she has to do it by either leaving him to turn or pulling the trigger herself. It’s not a decision a child should ever face, but this world doesn’t care about childhood.

And that’s what makes the ending feel so right. It’s unfair, abrupt, and deeply painful, but it mirrors everything Lee fought against — that sense of lost innocence, the price of survival, and the inevitability of loss. The series could’ve easily given him a miraculous escape, but it wouldn’t have meant as much. The ending hurt because it was earned.

3

Shadow of the Colossus

When The Giants Fall, So Do The Innocent

Systems

Released

October 18, 2005

ESRB

T For Teen // Blood, Fantasy Violence

What starts as a quiet, melancholic tale of love and sacrifice turns into a slow realization that nothing about this quest is noble. Shadow of the Colossus doesn’t have traditional villains — just sixteen towering colossi who never attack first, many of whom are simply minding their own business until Wander climbs onto their backs with a sword in hand.

Players spend hours slaying these massive creatures, each more awe-inspiring than the last, only to discover they are ancient guardians keeping a malevolent force sealed away. And every time one falls, Wander gets a little more corrupted — physically and spiritually — until he’s unrecognizable.

The ending lands like a stone on the chest. Wander’s body is twisted beyond saving, the woman he tried to bring back awakens but never gets to truly see him, and the price of his obsession echoes long after the credits. There’s no victory in what he did. Just consequences. The final scene, with a child born from the ashes of a cursed man, is the only glimmer of hope — and even that feels like a faint whisper in a story drenched in regret.

2

The Last of Us Part 2

No One Really Wins When Revenge Is The Goal

Systems

Released

June 19, 2020

ESRB

M for Mature: Blood and Gore, Intense Violence, Nudity, Sexual Content, Strong Language, Use of Drugs

Few stories have sparked as much debate as The Last of Us Part II, and it’s not hard to see why. This is a game that spends 30 hours making players feel every inch of pain, resentment, and grief that comes from a cycle of revenge that refuses to break.

Related

8 JRPGs With Thought-Provoking Endings

These JRPGs end their stories in some fantastic, poignant ways.

Ellie’s journey isn’t about justice. It’s about anger that festers until it consumes everything. The story doesn’t shy away from making players sit with that discomfort — forcing them to walk in Abby’s shoes, feel the humanity of the supposed villain, and then come full circle to question who deserved what.

The final moments don’t offer catharsis. Ellie loses her loved ones, her home, and even the ability to play Joel’s guitar — the last link to the person she was avenging. And when she finally lets Abby go, it doesn’t feel triumphant. It feels like defeat. But that’s exactly what makes it honest. In a story about how pain poisons everything it touches, a clean, happy ending would’ve felt like a lie.

1

Red Dead Redemption

A Man Can’t Outrun The Past, No Matter How Noble The Present

Released

May 18, 2010

Developer(s)

Rockstar San Diego

ESRB

M For Mature 17+ Due To Blood, Intense Violence, Nudity, Strong Language, Strong Sexual Content, Use of Drugs

The final moments of Red Dead Redemption are the kind that never quite leaves. John Marston spends the whole story trying to leave his outlaw past behind, building fences, tending his ranch, and trying to give his family the peace he never had. But the world doesn’t forgive as easily as he does.

After everything he does for the government — tracking down his old gang, enduring betrayal after betrayal — the ending hits like a gut punch. A firing squad waits for him in his own barn. He knows it but still opens the door. There’s no final shootout where he emerges victorious. Just a last stand, a hail of bullets, and the realization that redemption is rarely ever rewarded.

Even worse, Jack’s epilogue isn’t about healing. It’s about vengeance. He grows up and kills the man responsible, mirroring the same cycle John tried to escape. It’s a deliberately bleak ending that says more with its hopelessness than any happy ending could have. Marston dies a hero, but it doesn’t change the world. And that’s what makes it hurt.

More

11 Best Happy Endings In Horror Games

The horror genre isn’t exactly known for being wholesome, but these games, both horror and adventure, have surprisingly happy endings.