Most Unlikeable Horror Game Protagonists

As the character that the player is going to spend the most time with during their playthrough, it is important that the protagonist of any game is a figure that they can engage with on some level. The hero is usually relatable and easy to sympathize with, while some are unlikable on purpose, turning out to be characters that players love to hate.

In horror games, there are plenty of main characters that are problematic, although these games tend to examine their rationale and present a chance to confront their flaws. Yet, despite developers’ best attempts to craft well-rounded and authentic protagonists, unfortunately, some insufferable ones slip through the cracks. These are some of the most unlikable horror game protagonists, from the irredeemably annoying to the inexcusable wrongdoers.

Related

8 Bravest Horror Game Protagonists

Bravery comes in many forms, as do monsters, but with these horror game protagonists leading the charge, players can strike back with heroism.

Spoiler Warning: some of these entries contain spoilers

10

Alex Smith (Man Of Medan)

Being Boring Can Be A Deal-Breaker

OpenCritic

Top Critic Rating:
71/100

Released

August 30, 2019

Multiplayer

Online Multiplayer

Expand

A majority of the unlikable characters in Supermassive’s games are intentionally so, with many of them having cliquey attitudes or a frustrating lack of social skills that align with their backstory. Man of Medan is the first title in the Dark Pictures Anthology series of games.

Alex Smith is (respectively) the boyfriend and brother of two other playable characters, Julia and Brad. His insecurities around his and Julia’s relationship seem to be his entire personality, which otherwise falls disappointingly flat. Despite being a rational character, his lack of development makes Alex difficult to like.

9

Luca (MADiSON)

Notoriously Annoying Voice Acting

OpenCritic

Top Critic Rating:
74/100

Released

July 8, 2022

Developer(s)

BLOODIOUS GAMES

Beyond other issues like the inventory system and save bugs, MADiSON has been criticized for having an annoying protagonist. Luca points out the obvious often and very loudly — which, when being stalked by demons, is not well-received as it massively breaks the immersion.

The character letdown is unfortunate, as MADiSON is an otherwise genuinely scary game, if somewhat derivative of P.T. With a gripping narrative, unique mechanics, and unnerving soundscape, players shouldn’t let Luca deter them from playing. To the relief of many, there is a mute option.

8

The Painter (Layers Of Fear)

Career Before Family

OpenCritic

Top Critic Rating:
74/100

Franchise

Layers of Fear

Released

February 16, 2016

Some protagonists are unlikable in a moral sense. Unlike Silent Hill 2′s James Sunderland, who has a complex motive and apparent genuine remorse for his actions, the Painter in Layers of Fear is hard to sympathize with, pushing the limits of the “tortured artist” appeal.

4:20

Related

20 Best Psychological Horror Games

Horror fans shouldn’t pass up on these titles, which are considered by many to be the best psychological horror games out there.

Admittedly, he was evidently unwell and, likewise, his wife was by no means a saint. Their marriage struggled beforehand with jealous toxicity and drinking problems. However, the Painter’s blatant disregard and sensitivity to his wife’s condition, and his neglect of their daughter, leave a lot to desire.

7

P-3 (Atomic Heart)

The Nihilistic Persona Gets Old

OpenCritic

Top Critic Rating:
74/100

Released

February 21, 2023

Developer(s)

Mundfish

P-3 is a spec ops agent and the protagonist of Atomic Heart. Granted, he has traumatic brain damage and has just been thrown into a dystopian world of biomechanical body horrors and hostile robots, but his lines can become repetitive and offer little in the way of being productive for the player.

Many feel that these issues are largely due to translation. Much like a lot of anime dubs, P-3’s translated dialogue doesn’t land the way it’s intended to, drawing away from the immersion and becoming rather grating. Playing with the original Russian voice over makes P-3 much more tolerable.

6

Kyle Crane (Dying Light)

A Case Of Cognitive Dissonance

OpenCritic

Top Critic Rating:
74/100

Franchise

Dying Light

Released

January 27, 2015

Publisher(s)

Warner Bros. Games

Multiplayer

Online Co-Op

Expand

Dying Light is a zombie survival horror following undercover agent Kyle Crane, who is dropped in the middle of a conflict between bandits, survivors, and the GRE. Being pulled from multiple angles, it’s no wonder that Crane has some moral difficulties, but many players find him disingenuous.

Throughout the game, Crane’s dialogue and attitude are often in direct opposition to his actions. Despite openly being against some of his objectives, he ends up doing them anyway. Lots of fans of the game would prefer to see Kyle standing up for himself more through actions.

5

Daniel (Amnesia: The Dark Descent)

Committed Atrocious Crimes

Released

September 8, 2010

The Amnesia franchise has its fair share of abominable protagonists who have committed terrible crimes, from delusional sacrifices to twisted experiments. One that stands out in particular, however, is Daniel from The Dark Descent.

Related

8 Best Horror Games That Play On Your Fear Of Death

The fear of death is a strong one. These horror games play on that fear in both their story and gameplay to give players a memorable experience.

Unlike the other protagonists, Daniel committed his doings prior to drinking the amnesia potion while still of sound mind, albeit afraid. Despite acting desperately out of an understandable fear of death, it’s undeniably selfish to kill so many to save himself. He altogether seems more vengeful than remorseful.

4

Abby (The Last Of Us Part 2)

Skewed Priorities & Unsympathetic

Systems

OpenCritic

Top Critic Rating:
93/100

Franchise

The Last of Us

Released

June 19, 2020

The Last of Us Part 2 follows two opposing protagonists, Ellie and Abby (whose father was the Firefly Doctor that Joel killed). Whether any of the main characters were really “good” or “bad” is debatable; the emotional and political contexts make matters of morality significantly more complex.

Nonetheless, Abby became the target of a lot of hate, and it’s not impossible to see why. Messing with fan favorites is bound to stir up resentment. Torturing and killing Joel, a beloved character, gained her instant bad rep. She also has little hesitation shooting her fellow WLF members and almost kills Dina, knowing she was pregnant.

3

Frank West (Dead Rising 4)

Character Assassination

OpenCritic

Top Critic Rating:
72/100

Franchise

Dead Rising

Released

December 6, 2016

Developer(s)

Capcom Vancouver

Publisher(s)

Microsoft Studios

Multiplayer

Online Multiplayer, Local Multiplayer

Expand

After the enjoyable horde hack-and-slashing of the previous games, Dead Rising 4 came as something of a disappointment in terms of both story and combat, not to mention the stark changes in the recurring character, Frank West.

Once a charming, witty protagonist, in this title Frank is immature and almost unrecognizable in personality. There is a running joke in the community that this Frank is actually a different character, “Hank East”. Something has gone seriously wrong when fans make up their own headcanons to excuse the poor characterization.

2

Ellen (The Witch’s House)

Malicious & Deceitful

Released

October 31, 2018

The Witch’s House is a 2D pixel horror following a young girl, Viola, as she seeks refuge in a mansion while trying to escape the forest she woke up in. Navigating the puzzles and traps, it soon becomes apparent that there is something much more sinister afoot, going by the name of Ellen.

Related

7 Terrifying Pixel Graphics Horror Games

Good horror doesn’t need to rely on fancy graphics. These games with pixel graphics can still scare the pants off players.

This game has one of the most tragic twists in horror games, with the main character, Viola, being revealed to be Ellen herself: a girl who switched bodies with Viola and tricked her into making the swap permanent. The secret ending elaborates on the brutal way Ellen went about doing so, evaporating all sympathy for who is, at first, portrayed as a sickly young girl.

1

Jimmy (Mouthwashing)

Committed Unjustified & Unforgivable Offences

Systems

OpenCritic

Top Critic Rating:
83/100

Released

September 26, 2024

Developer(s)

Wrong Organ

Publisher(s)

Critical Reflex

Mouthwashing is an all-around disturbing game, complete with dark themes, tragic narratives, and unnerving visuals. The game follows the stranded crew of a crashed space freighter as they try to survive, and the subsequent fallout, including dwindling resources, relationship tensions, and physical trauma. Revelations about the player-character are difficult to come to terms with.

Eventually, the player has to come face to face with the fact that they have been controlling one of the most diabolical characters of all time, Jimmy — abusive, jealous, and murderous. They are led down a distressing path that reveals all the ugliness of his deeds and psyche. The eventual appearance of a guilty conscience, bringing with it a belief that he can redeem himself by saving another crew member, has the opposite effect of making Jimmy even more unlikable. There is no excuse or possible redemption for such a character.

More

8 Best Villains In Horror Games

Nothing beats a great villain in a horror game. Here’s which bad guys have become iconic over the years after their spooky first appearances.