Should You Replace Pebbles with Herring in Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2?

One of the most important things Henry can obtain during his journey in Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 is a horse. A mount makes it easier to travel between different points on the map, and also allows players to carry extra loot after defeating bandits and collecting items for the map. Most likely, the first horse acquired by players will be Pebbles, Henry’s mare found in the Semine stables.

However, as the story advances and the quest “For Whom the Bell Tolls” is completed and “Back In The Saddle” begins, Henry needs to decide whether to keep Pebbles as his horse or trade it for Herring, a new mount offered at the Trosky Castle stables for free. Although the new option seems better, a few things should be considered before making that decision.

Related

7 Best Early Horses In Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2

These are the best early horses in Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 that Henry can obtain for explore the map.

Is Pebbles Or Herring Better In Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2?

In the early game of Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2, Herring is often a more viable choice for players, since it surpasses Pebbles in Stamina, Speed, and Courage, as well as overall Value. Thus, it is an exchange that makes sense at this stage of the game, especially because it is offered to Henry for free and seems like a fair deal.

So, if players choose to stay with Herring in Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2, it becomes Henry’s main horse. Fortunately, if there is any regret later, up to a certain point in the main quest, it is possible to return to the Semine stables (where Pebbles was found for the first time). Here, players can either purchase it again from Groom Ballatay or steal it. This allows players to test which option is preferable and, if minds change, to keep the old companion.

Herring And Pebbles Have A Hidden Perk

Despite Herring’s stats, there are several reasons not to trade Pebbles for Herring in Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2. The first is that Pebbles is Henry’s longtime mare, accompanying him since the beginning of the first game. In addition, after riding more than 35km with it, there is a way to unlock a hidden perk called Good Old Pebbles, which provides a major boost to its attributes, making it one of the best horse options in the game.

Related

Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 – How To Get Perkpoints

Perkpoints are used to unlock perks in each skill tree and major stat in Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2; here’s how to get them.

The horse offered by Kabat in the Trosky Castle stables also has a secret perk, called Red Herring Perk, which similarly grants a large upgrade to its potential. However, unlocking it requires riding 50km with the mount, a considerably longer distance for an upgrade that does not differ much from Pebbles’.

Thus, the best choice for players tends to be keeping Pebbles. In addition to the backstory and connection the mare has with the protagonist from the first game, its carry capacity is much higher. Herring can provide more Stamina and a bit more Speed and Courage, but these differences usually do not greatly impact gameplay.

Kabat’s Offer

For those looking to earn money during the early game of Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2, there is yet another reason to remain with Pebbles. By informing Kabat of the decision to reject Herring, he suggests telling the Chamberlain that Henry accepted the horse but actually sells it to the Nomad, and rewards players with 300 Groschen for their cooperation. It is possible to perform a skill check to try to increase that amount.

Game

My Favorite Games
My Played Games
My Games Wishlist

RPG

Action-Adventure

Open-World

Systems

Released

February 4, 2025

ESRB

Mature 17+ // Use of Alcohol, Blood and Gore, Sexual Content, Strong Language, Intense Violence, Partial Nudity

Developer(s)

Warhorse Studios