The Best Undead Nightmare Sequel May Not Exactly Be Undead Nightmare 2

Posted by By our-little-miss-is-home February 1, 2025 6 Views 6 Min Read
The Best Undead Nightmare Sequel May Not Exactly Be Undead Nightmare 2



Views: 0

Summary

  • Fans have been hoping for a sequel to Red Dead Redemption: Undead Nightmare for 15 years.
  • Instead of zombies, a new Undead Nightmare could explore aliens based on hints in Rockstar’s previous games.
  • A potential title like “Unearthly Nightmare” could see Dutch’s gang facing extraterrestrial threats with humor and gameplay adjacent to the original Undead Nightmare.

Ever since it first burst from the grave in 2010, Red Dead Redemption: Undead Nightmare has remained a fan favorite that left many players craving more of it. The first and only DLC for RDR was perhaps a bit unexpected given the gritty realism and intense emotional journey of the main campaign, but with Red Dead Redemption: Undead Nightmare, Rockstar Games provided a separate story that was at turns scary and funny. It fit well into the detailed Old West setting and went on to become one of the most popular pieces of content in the series.

In the 15 years since its release, a second outing has been oft-requested, but the prospect has not yet come to fruition. If one were to crawl back onto the scene though, a new Undead Nightmare doesn’t necessarily have to be the same vision as the original’s zombie apocalypse. Another equally outlandish scenario that could serve as a basis is already set up, having been sighted in both Red Dead Redemption and Grand Theft Auto titles. The two franchises have contained hints and traces of aliens and UFOs, and while these have mostly been out-of-the-way secrets or brief Easter eggs so far, this could easily be expanded into a full-blown follow-up to Undead Nightmare.

Red Dead Redemption Undead Nightmare John Marston Fighting Bear

Related


Red Dead Redemption Shouldn’t Be the Last Time Rockstar Dabbles with the Fantastical

Rockstar dipped its toes into a peculiar genre twist during the Red Dead Redemption era, and the company will hopefully revisit this practice someday.

Rockstar Could Finally Pull the Trigger on All Its Alien Teasers in a Potential Undead Nightmare Successor

In what seemed to start as a rumor about Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas that rapidly circulated among fan forums, Rockstar hiding UFOs and aliens in its games later became a reality. The studio leaned into the rampant speculation and theories, and began to include hidden content referencing otherworldly visitors in subsequent releases. GTA 5 gave fans the most concrete evidence of UFOs until that point, and by the time of Red Dead Redemption 2, aliens were essentially confirmed to exist in both universes.

A Second Undead Nightmare Could Have a Field Day With a ‘Cowboys Versus Aliens’ Framework

While Red Dead Redemption 2 has a minor nod to Undead Nightmare, that’s the extent of its acknowledgment. On the other hand, RDR2‘s UFO encounter is the most elaborate yet, and provides a gateway to take it to its logical conclusion. The idea of extraterrestrials invading the Old West was basically the entire point of the 2011 film, Cowboys & Aliens, starring Harrison Ford and Daniel Craig. The movie (based on a graphic novel of the same name) delivered exactly what it advertised, and the premise would match neatly with Red Dead‘s world and gameplay.

With Undead Nightmare being a self-contained “What If?” spin-off, this gives Rockstar plenty of leeway to make another happen, only with an alien invasion instead of the dead returning to life. It could be set around one or more of the members of Dutch Van der Linde’s gang being abducted, and the rest of the crew having to rescue them while dealing with aliens running rampant across the frontier. This would make for more great moments of Undead Nightmare‘s humor in the narrative, especially if juxtaposed against Arthur Morgan’s stoic demeanor, while also having elements of terror as he faces a powerful threat from beyond Earth. Mechanically, it could also potentially give players some cool new toys to use, like ray-guns and teleporters.

Though most fans may be resigned at this point that it’s unlikely to happen, at least any time soon, there is still the possibility that someday they might get a sequel to Undead Nightmare. Given the demand for Rockstar to create more content similar to Undead Nightmare, and that aliens have long been present in its games, something like an “Unearthly Nightmare” DLC that embraces both aspects would work quite well and be truly welcome.

Source link