Even If It Lacks Multiplayer, Hogwarts Legacy 2 Can Improve By Studying an Unlikely Franchise

Posted by By our-little-miss-is-home January 6, 2025 9 Views 7 Min Read
Even If It Lacks Multiplayer, Hogwarts Legacy 2 Can Improve By Studying an Unlikely Franchise



Hogwarts Legacy smashed sales records and became 2023’s best-selling game by quite a significant margin—something that seems obvious in hindsight, considering the ubiquity of its source material. Despite the controversial statements from Warner Bros. about wanting to move away from single-player games and double-down on live-services, Hogwarts Legacy seems to succeed in spite of its lack of multiplayer, or perhaps even because of it.

This doesn’t mean that the ship has sailed on multiplayer features in the Hogwarts Legacy franchise. After all, if Warner Bros. is looking to the live-service model for greater profits and longevity, then it would make a lot of sense, for better or worse, to add online functionality to a future entry. Hogwarts Legacy 2, when it eventually comes out, will almost certainly sell like hotcakes regardless of its overall quality, but poorly implemented multiplayer options could dilute the strengths established by the first game. Thus, a more deft touch may be warranted.

Hogwarts Legacy New Protagonist

Related


Hogwarts Legacy 2 Can Kill Two Birds With One Stone With a New Protagonist

Hogwarts Legacy 2 seems practically guaranteed at this point, and it could kill two birds with one stone if it offered a completely new protagonist.

Hogwarts Legacy 2 Can Look to Animal Crossing for Subtle Multiplayer Features

Animal Crossing’s Dream Islands System Could Work for Hogwarts Legacy 2’s Room of Requirement

In Animal Crossing: New Horizons, the player can be visited by Luna, a spectral entity, while they sleep. This opens the door to Dream Islands, digital copies of other players’ islands that can be visited without the need to interact with the hosts or add them to one’s friend list. Players can either search for specific islands through a Dream Address, or be transported to a random one. While visiting a Dream Island, the player cannot interact with the island’s owner, nor can they make any changes to its layout, item composition, et cetera.

It’s not hard to imagine a version of this appearing in Hogwarts Legacy, specifically pertaining to the Room of Requirement. Through the Room of Requirement, Hogwarts Legacy is injected with a healthy dose of “cozy game” energy, as the Room is a venue for creative expression, low-stakes customization, and resource-gathering via activities like potion-brewing and gardening. The unfortunate thing about the Room of Requirement is that the player’s hard work can never be shared with others. It’s not like other cozy games like Animal Crossing or even Stardew Valley, wherein players can show off their personalized worlds through co-op features.

But if players could visit each other’s Rooms of Requirement, Hogwarts Legacy 2‘s personalization systems would be far more rewarding. Maybe the game could even feature something like a guest book, allowing players to leave short reviews of the Rooms they visit. Implementing this through something like Animal Crossing‘s Dream Islands feature would make the system less intrusive and immersion-breaking, as players wouldn’t actually be interacting with each other, just visiting immutable versions of their personal spaces.

The Potential Downside of Hogwarts Legacy 2 Adopting a ‘Dream Islands’ System

To be frank, if Warner Bros. is planning on being bullish about future live-service ventures, it isn’t because the company believes such experiences are what gamers are asking for; Warner Bros. and other major companies publishing live-service games are doing so because they are seeking the profits associated with the likes of Fortnite. Player enjoyment is necessary for profit generation, but it’s a means to an end.

If Hogwarts Legacy 2 were to implement any sort of multiplayer functionality, there’s a good chance it would be monetized in some way. How this could be reflected in the proposed Dream Island system (or any RoR-visiting feature) is through paid cosmetics. “Premium” furniture and decor could be sold at an in-game store, preying on players’ sense of FOMO and inferiority. Everyone would want the “best” Room of Requirement, so it would be easy to nudge them in the direction of microtransactions to meet this goal. Other Rooms of Requirement with premium decor would effectively become free advertising for these in-game purchases, making for a potentially predatory monetization scheme.

Source link