The Gathering May Never Reprint One Classic Card in Standard

Posted by By our-little-miss-is-home December 27, 2024 7 Views 6 Min Read
The Gathering May Never Reprint One Classic Card in Standard



Summary

  • Lightning Bolt is iconic in Magic: The Gathering due to its strong, versatile 1 Red mana for 3 damage.
  • Lightning Bolt’s low cost results in faster, aggressive metas and poses problems for Standard formats.
  • Unlikely to return to Standard due to balancing concerns and Mark Rosewater’s comments.

With the many competitive formats in Magic: The Gathering and a catalog of cards that goes back over thirty years, it’s inevitable that some cards are left out here and there, be it because of rotating sets or Wizards of the Coast’s decisions. For example, some cards end up being banned because they are too strong in the current meta in some formats and not others, even if they’re normally available there. The recent December 2024 MTG Banned and Restricted post made a lot of changes to Modern, but not to Standard because the format is in a decent spot at the moment. Even with great reprints in the Foundations set, one Magic: The Gathering classic is still missing in Standard – and for good reason.

One of the biggest problems with balancing Magic: The Gathering formats is that even adding or removing a single card can cause huge splashes in the meta, determining which cards may be good to use and which may not be optimal. This can be especially true for removals, as each deck tends to have at least a few in order to eliminate potential threats to their game plan, and with removals that also deal damage to players, it can be harder still to balance them. This is why Lightning Bolt may never be reprinted in Standard.

magic-the-gathering-mtg-creatures-with-partner-cards-companions-deckbuilding-commander-banned-formats-powerful-broken-no-reprints-new-cards-good-bad

Related


Two Magic: The Gathering Card Types May Never Be Printed Again

Magic: The Gathering has many card types and subtypes, but two of them are problematic enough that they may never get new prints.

Why Magic: The Gathering is Unlikely to Reprint Lightning Bolt in Standard

Lightning Bolt is one of the oldest and most popular cards in the entirety of Magic: The Gathering, and it’s also one of the most iconic, often seeing play wherever it’s legal. The reason is very simple, and it’s because Lightning Bolt is a very strong card. With a CMC of 1 (specifically, 1 Red mana), it deals three damage to any target. That means that it can damage any Creature or player, but it doesn’t work against Magic: The Gathering‘s Planeswalkers or Battles, for example.

Still, Lightning Bolt is very reliable and versatile, and it’s rarely a “dead card,” meaning one of those cards one may draw that are not particularly useful at certain stages of a game. Having Lighting Bolt in Standard, which has happened in the past, can end up determining which Creatures are good to play and which are not, as anything with toughness 3 or less can be removed with just one mana. On top of that, it can also damage players, meaning that one can close out games much faster with four copies of Lightning Bolt, regardless of the Magic: The Gathering format it’s available in.

Mark Rosewater May Have Put The Final Nail in Lightning Bolt’s Coffin

The "Lightning Bolt" card featuring Storm from Magic: the Gathering's Marvel crossover.

Recently, Magic: The Gathering‘s own Mark Rosewater commented on his blog regarding Lightning Bolt’s viability in Standard, precisely mentioning how it can be problematic in terms of determining which Creatures are viable in the format due to its low cost and effectiveness at three damage to Creatures or players. Given that Lightning Bolt already proved controversial in Magic: The Gathering‘s Standard format, and given that MaRo himself doesn’t seem inclined to bring it back, it’s quite unlikely to return.

The problem is that cards like Lightning Bolt make for a much faster and more aggressive meta, as one has to account both for an efficient removal and the fact that it can be used as “burn,” meaning a card that deals direct damage to players. It’s unclear what 2025 will bring to Magic: The Gathering in terms of new cards, but with a classic like Lightning Bolt not being in Foundations and being discussed as problematic by MaRo, its chances of a Standard reprint are pretty low.

Source link