Characters Who Should Not Return In The Witcher 4

Summary

• Dijkstra’s poor handling in Witcher 3 makes his return unappealing in Witcher 4.
• Keira Metz had decent screen time but doesn’t need to appear in Witcher 4.
• Avoid bringing back Avallac’h to prevent rehashing old plots in Ciri’s narrative.

The announcement of The Witcher 4 has sent the entire gaming world into a fervor. Fans can’t wait to control Ciri as she hunts down monsters and gets embroiled in an epic tale where she’ll cross several enemies and try to do the right thing as often as possible.

As one would expect, The Witcher 4 is bound to feature the return of beloved characters as they interact with Ciri during her quest. However, there are some established personalities who are better off taking a backseat in Ciri’s adventure to ensure that this story feels original.

8 Sigismund Dijkstra

His Arc Was Poorly Handled In The Witcher 3, Which Makes His Return Less Appealing

• Appears In:The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

Dijkstra is a wily character from the books who’s wise and completes underhanded deals with great flair. This expertise is missing in The Witcher 3, where Dijkstra can be undermined and made a fool of time and time again.

If players go ahead with Radovid’s assassination, then Dijkstra carries out a foolhardy betrayal that can only end one way unless players decide to do nothing as he slaughters some of Geralt’s closest allies. He should stay dead since it’s clear that Dijkstra won’t have the same impact anymore even if CD Projekt Red finds an excuse to bring him back.

7 Keira Metz

The Mage Had Decent Screentime in The Previous Game And Doesn’t Need To Appear Again

• Appears In:The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

A sorceress who yearns to live a comfortable life once again, Keira’s simple motivation leads to her trying to outsmart Geralt and get in the good graces of Radovid. It’s a stupid plan borne out of desperation that Geralt can talk her out of, but the sorceress’ fate is usually a grisly one.

She will either fall at Geralt’s hand or be impaled by Radovid, with the latter being a consequence that anyone could’ve predicted. Some fans may appreciate her in The Witcher 4, but most people would prefer other original magicians to play a central role instead of her.

6 Avallac’h

His Appearance Would Lead To Old Plots And Resolved Arcs Being Rehashed

• Appears In:The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

Avallac’h’s character has played a major role in Ciri’s development across the books and the third Witcher game. With the White Frost being eliminated, there’s no reason to bring him back for her adventure even if he shares a bond with her.

Instead, Ciri should focus on other adventures that do justice to her new persona instead of rehashing plot points. The possibilities are endless, and there’s no reason why the game should rely on such lazy writing to keep fans hooked.

5 Shani

Her Connection To Ciri Is Lacking, Making It Hard To Justify Her Presence

• Appears In:The Witcher, The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

There’s no denying that fans were glad to see Shani make a return after being AWOL for a long time. However, this is mainly because Geralt is the protagonist who shares a history with her from the first game.

In Ciri’s case, she has no connections to Shani, which may seem like the game is forcing her into the fledgling witcher’s narrative in The Witcher 4. A lot of time may have passed between The Witcher 3 and its upcoming sequel, which may make it even harder to justify Shani’s inclusion.

4 Philippa Eilhart

It’s Time For The Witcher To Move On From A Character Who Played A Huge Role For Most Of The Witcher Series

• Appears In:The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings, The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

Philippa is one of the most important characters in the novels, with her presence being critical to creating the powerful Lodge of Sorceresses. She served as an antagonist for the bulk of the second game before getting her comeuppance at Radovid’s hands, who blinded her.

She was a shadow of her former self in The Witcher 3, with her sole purpose being to take out Radovid and get her revenge. It would be farcical to bring her back in The Witcher 4 when it would be better to focus on other sorceresses who are just as powerful and can go through unique character arcs of their own.

3 Triss Merigold

Her Connection To Ciri Isn’t As Strong As That Of Geralt And Yennefer

• Appears In:The Witcher, The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings, The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

A lot of people love Triss for sticking with Geralt across the video game trilogy, even if her role wasn’t nearly as important in the books. However, with Geralt’s journey drawing to a satisfying close in the games, it’s easy to see why justifying her inclusion may be harder.

Geralt and Yennefer serve as Ciri’s guardians. Triss is more of an outsider who helped Ciri out at one point in the books but didn’t raise her voice when the Lodge tried to abuse her Source powers. This makes her connection to Ciri feel quite forced, which is the last thing players would want to deal with.

2 Zoltan Chivay

Ciri Can Interact With Original Characters Instead Of Meeting Geralt’s Past Acquaintances

• Appears In:The Witcher, The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings, The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

Zoltan Chivay is a dwarf who’s been with Geralt through thick and thin in the games, even if his presence may not have been all that noticeable in the books. He’s a loudmouthed warrior with a heart of gold whom players loved to interact with throughout the three games.

However, Zoltan has also made so many appearances that players would prefer another dwarf to aid Ciri in her adventures again. He technically served as Yarpen Zigrin’s replacement from the books, and seeing him in The Witcher 4 instead of Zoltan would be a great treat for fans who miss his boisterous presence.

1 Vernon Roche

Players Would Prefer Iorveth’s Return Over Another Unsatisfying Cameo By Vernon Roche

• Appears In:The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings, The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

The Witcher 3 faced its fair share of cuts before release, which is why Vernon’s presence in the game can feel rather forced. A lot of content surrounding this character is removed, to the point where players don’t even get to interact with another Witcher 2 character who could’ve made a huge impact in Geralt’s final game.

Since Vernon is a human and The Witcher 4 seemingly takes place many years after the original trilogy ended, an aged Vernon may not make for the most compelling cameo. Meanwhile, Iorveth is an elf with a lengthy lifespan whose inclusion in The Witcher 4 will feel more natural and serve as a joyous moment for fans of The Witcher 2 who miss this Scoia’tael leader.

• 

  Systems

  

  Released

  October 30, 2007

•