Hogwarts Legacy’s Sequel Must Give One Character Its Significance Back

Posted by By our-little-miss-is-home December 10, 2024 129 Views 7 Min Read
Hogwarts Legacy’s Sequel Must Give One Character Its Significance Back
Views: 0

Hogwarts Legacy is open-ended with player choice as it pertains to customization and personalization as a Hogwarts student and that includes giving players their preferred house selection regardless of what the Sorting Hat might declare. In Philosopher’s/Sorcerer’s Stone, the thrill of the Sorting Hat is its pinpoint precision in almost instantly deciding which house a first-year student should be in.




Of course, there’s always been debate about whether the Hat’s choices have been accurate or a fair judgment of the student’s character; just because Ron Weasley is in fact a Weasley shouldn’t necessarily mean he’s a shoo-in for Gryffindor, for example, as not every sibling in a family is likely to share the same personality traits or morals. Still, the decision being largely out of students’ hands is arguably what makes enrollment exciting. Having been given the freedom to change the Hat’s mind in Hogwarts Legacy, it would be terrific if that is how enrollment is tackled in a sequel.

a (1)-17

Related
The Lord of the Rings Hasn’t Had Its ‘Hogwarts Legacy’ Yet and That’s a Crying Shame

Hogwarts Legacy will likely shape the future Harry Potter games while The Lord of the Rings is still aching for a similar action-RPG experience.

Hogwarts Legacy’s Sorting Hat is Superficial for the Sake of Player Choice


Harry Potter’s Sorting Hat is an iconic item/character and has only ever been prevalent when it comes to actually sorting first-year witches and wizards as they first enter Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry’s Great Hall for the Sorting Ceremony. Here, whether it’s deemed judgmental, perceptive, unconditional, or stereotypical, the Hat is revered and allowed to decide what Hogwarts house a student will be enrolled in for the full seven years of their magical schooling.

In
Hogwarts Legacy
, however,
players decide their Hogwarts house
—which is purportedly what the Hat’s Legilimency facilitates, but there seemingly wouldn’t be any point to the Sorting Hat if students could choose for themselves what house they believe they might enjoy most.


Players do get to more or less create a semblance of what it’d be like to have the Hat assign them a house, though this is achieved via a guided and transparent personality quiz that unsubtly has players decide for themselves in a roundabout and explicit way. This can essentially be interpreted as the Hat’s methodology in nearly instantly being able to dissect a person and understand their leading traits.

Indeed, some players might feel slighted if RNG was to assign them to Slytherin when they’d normally ascribe themselves to Gryffindor, for instance. Now that the house selection process has been given to players in such a basic and spoonfed manner, though, it would be great to see a Hogwarts Legacy sequel fully commit to whatever the Sorting Hat arbitrarily chooses for the player via RNG.

Hogwarts Legacy’s Sequel Should Fully Pick Players’ Houses for Them

Players who are enormous fans of Harry Potter and have taken quizzes online to determine what house they would be sorted into, let alone anyone who has an unwavering idea of what house they would be in otherwise, will always have a house or two they may have wished to be enrolled in, and RNG wouldn’t always meet their expectations. In a perfect scenario, it would be exhilarating and immersive if RNG selected a house for the player because their avatar may not always be intended as an extension of themselves but as a separate character.


Of course, if Harry Potter was able to dissuade the Hat and have himself put into Gryffindor instead it makes sense why players should be able to choose their house. Most students probably aren’t surprised to be where the Sorting Hat had selected, and they’d never know what it is like being in any other house.

Either way, stripping that choice away from players could make house-exclusive quests more thrilling since players won’t know which house they’ll be in until the Hat sorts them, at which point they can be excited for whatever quests await them. Plus, if players truly despised the choice the Hat made, they could be free to start the sequel over or save scum to see a different result.

Then, in a hopeful New Game Plus playthrough, giving players the choice to have the Hat reconsider its choice would be great if, say, RNG landed on the same house players were given in their original playthrough. All of this would be well and good for a sequel to contemplate, and yet it’s unknown at the moment what the narrative of Hogwarts Legacy’s successor will be like, much less if players will be getting sorted into a Hogwarts house at all.


Source link